| 2002 | 2003 |
|---|---|
 WCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Sean Connally |
WCLL Honorable Mention All Conference: Sean Connally |
| 2004 | 2005 |
|---|---|
| WCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Aaron Klett |
 USLIA Scholar Athlete: Aaron Klett |
| WCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Aaron Klett & Bryce VanKooten |
| 2006 | 2007 |
|---|---|
| USLIA 3rd Team All America: Aaron Klett |
 MCLA 2nd Team All America: Bryce VanKooten |
| WCLL 1st Team All Conference: Josh Agadoni, Aaron Klett, Matt Williams & Bryce VanKooten |
MCLA 3rd Team All America: Ben Agadoni |
| WCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Tim Mann |
MCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce VanKooten & Ben Agadoni |
| WCLL 1st Team All Conference: Bryce VanKooten & Stephen Schuil |
|
| WCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Ben Agadoni |
| 2008 | 2009 |
|---|---|
| MCLA 1st Team All America: Ben Agadoni |
 SLC 1st Team All Conference: Adam Kingston |
| MCLA 2nd Team All America: Ryan Smith |
SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Brad Westcott, John Crowell & Jordan Adams |
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: Matt Hiett |
SLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Billy McMahan, Garrett Wragg, Matt Hiett & Jonathan Lowell |
| WCLL 1st Team All Conference: Ben Agadoni, Brad Westcott, Jordan Adams, Ryan Smith & Matt Hiett |
|
| WCLL Offensive Player of the Year: Ben Agadoni |
|
| WCLL Defensive Player of the Year: Ryan Smith |
| 2010 | 2011 |
|---|---|
| MCLA Honorable Mention All America: Jordan Adams & Patrick Murphy |
MCLA Honorable Mention All America: Jeff Clark & Justin Harrington |
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: John Crowell & Justin Harrington |
SLC 1st Team All Conference: Jeff Clark & Marc Morgan |
| SLC 1st Team All Conference: Adam Kingston, Jordan Adams, Justin Harrington & Patrick Murphy |
SLC 2nd Team All Conference: David Sigley |
| SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Billy McMahan, John Crowell & Jonathan Lowell |
| 2012 | 2013 |
|---|---|
| SLC 1st Team All Conference: Jeff Clark |
SLC All Freshman: David Shaum |
| SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Adam Kingston |
|
| SLC All Freshman: Matt Young |
| 2014 | 2015 |
|---|---|
| MCLA Honorable Mention All America: David Shaum |
SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Riley Corbett |
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: Justin Ahn, David Shaum & Bryce Hummel |
|
| SLC 1st Team All Conference: David Shaum |
|
| SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard, Bryce Hummel, Justin Ahn & John Harzan |
|
| SLC All Freshman: Jon Prichard, Bryce Hummel & John Harzan |
| 2016 | 2017 |
|---|---|
| MCLA Honorable Mention All America: Bryce Hummel |
MCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce Hummel & Matt Casto |
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce Hummel |
SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard |
| SLC 1st Team All Conference: Bryce Hummel |
SLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Bryce Hummel & Matt Casto |
| SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard |
SLC All Freshman: Jacob Newport |
| 2018 | 2019 |
|---|---|
| MCLA Honorable Mention All America: Peter Williamson |
SLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Jacob Newport |
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: Peter Williamson, Garrison Thompson & Josh Bernstein |
SLC All Freshman: Caleb Koopman |
| SLC 2nd Team All Conference: Peter Williamson |
|
| SLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Garrison Thompson & Josh Bernstein |
| 2022 | |
|---|---|
| MCLA Scholar Athlete: Henry Beck |
|
| SLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Henry Beck & Jacob Kaholokula |