2002 2003
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Sean Connally Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL Honorable Mention All Conference: Sean Connally
2004 2005
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Aaron Klett US Lacrosse LogoUSLIA Scholar Athlete: Aaron Klett
  Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Aaron Klett & Bryce VanKooten
2006 2007
US Lacrosse LogoUSLIA 3rd Team All America: Aaron Klett Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA 2nd Team All America: Bryce VanKooten
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 1st Team All Conference: Josh Agadoni, Aaron Klett, Matt Williams & Bryce VanKooten Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA 3rd Team All America: Ben Agadoni
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Tim Mann Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce VanKooten & Ben Agadoni
  Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 1st Team All Conference: Bryce VanKooten & Stephen Schuil
  Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 2nd Team All Conference: Ben Agadoni
2008 2009
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA 1st Team All America: Ben Agadoni Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: Adam Kingston
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA 2nd Team All America: Ryan Smith Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Brad Westcott, John Crowell & Jordan Adams
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Matt Hiett Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Billy McMahan, Garrett Wragg, Matt Hiett & Jonathan Lowell
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL 1st Team All Conference: Ben Agadoni, Brad Westcott, Jordan Adams, Ryan Smith & Matt Hiett  
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL Offensive Player of the Year: Ben Agadoni  
Western Collegiate Lacrosse League LogoWCLL Defensive Player of the Year: Ryan Smith  
2010 2011
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Honorable Mention All America: Jordan Adams & Patrick Murphy Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Honorable Mention All America: Jeff Clark & Justin Harrington
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: John Crowell & Justin Harrington Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: Jeff Clark & Marc Morgan
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: Adam Kingston, Jordan Adams, Justin Harrington & Patrick Murphy Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: David Sigley
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Billy McMahan, John Crowell & Jonathan Lowell  
2012 2013
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: Jeff Clark Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC All Freshman: David Shaum
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Adam Kingston  
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC All Freshman: Matt Young  
2014 2015
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Honorable Mention All America: David Shaum Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Riley Corbett
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Justin Ahn, David Shaum & Bryce Hummel  
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: David Shaum  
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard, Bryce Hummel, Justin Ahn & John Harzan  
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC All Freshman: Jon Prichard, Bryce Hummel & John Harzan  
2016 2017
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Honorable Mention All America: Bryce Hummel Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce Hummel & Matt Casto
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Bryce Hummel Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 1st Team All Conference: Bryce Hummel Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Bryce Hummel & Matt Casto
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Jon Prichard Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC All Freshman: Jacob Newport
2018 2019
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Honorable Mention All America: Peter Williamson Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Jacob Newport
Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association LogoMCLA Scholar Athlete: Peter Williamson, Garrison Thompson & Josh Bernstein Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC All Freshman: Caleb Koopman
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC 2nd Team All Conference: Peter Williamson  
Southwestern Lacrosse Conference LogoSLC Honorable Mention All Conference: Garrison Thompson & Josh Bernstein